10-06-2009, 02:32 PM
I haven't been protecting anybody. I have given my thoughts on everybody so far...
And your logic only works if you are correct about them being in the Mafia...
Nobody is ruled out indefinitely from the list at all. Everybody on the list are still possible Mafia members. You are basing your logic on certainty that Egon is in the mafia or I am in the mafia or whatever, but you aren't sure so you can't rule anybody out yet.
We'll only know for sure if we get the first vote right on who is in the Mafia. If we do then we can assume from the person's previous votes and so on like you're doing.
Also why didn't you put yourself on the list? Hmm....
And your logic only works if you are correct about them being in the Mafia...
Nobody is ruled out indefinitely from the list at all. Everybody on the list are still possible Mafia members. You are basing your logic on certainty that Egon is in the mafia or I am in the mafia or whatever, but you aren't sure so you can't rule anybody out yet.
We'll only know for sure if we get the first vote right on who is in the Mafia. If we do then we can assume from the person's previous votes and so on like you're doing.
Also why didn't you put yourself on the list? Hmm....